The P-M interaction curve at an angle: what it means for biaxial bending

Most columns are designed with one P-M curve about the strong axis and one about the weak axis. But a corner column, a column in a skewed frame, or any column under wind or seismic load from a diagonal direction carries an axial load and moments about both axes at the same time. Its strength in that situation is described by the P-M interaction curve at an angle.

PM Curve · 9 min read

Biaxial bending is the normal case

A column in a building frame picks up moment from the beams framing into it on both sides. Interior columns with balanced spans may see mostly axial load, but corner columns have beams in two directions and one-sided loading in both. Edge columns, columns supporting transfer beams, and columns in frames that are not square to each other all carry a moment Muz about one axis and Muy about the other, together with the axial load Pu.

Lateral loads add to it. Wind and earthquakes do not only arrive along the building's grid lines, and ASCE 7 requires seismic load combinations with 100% of the load in one direction plus 30% in the other. Every one of those combinations bends the column about a skewed axis.

The full strength of a column section is a three-dimensional surface in P, Mz and My. The Z and Y interaction curves are just two slices through it. The curve at an angle θ is another slice, taken in any direction you choose.

What the curve at an angle is

For bending about Z, the neutral axis is parallel to the section's width and the top face is in compression. For bending about Y it is turned through 90°. For a curve at an angle θ, the neutral axis is turned by θ, and the depth of every point in the section is measured along the direction n, at θ from the Y axis, instead of straight down.

ZYnθ = 30°compression cornerneutral axiscompression block, a = β₁cbar in compressionbar in tensionneutral axis, c = 14.47 inBalanced point at θ = 30°Pn = 498 kipMz = 502.5 kip-ftMy = 75.1 kip-ftMθ = 472.8 kip-ft
A 14 × 24 in tied column with 10-#9 bars, f′c = 4 ksi, fy = 60 ksi, at its balanced point for θ = 30°, from PM Curve. The neutral axis is perpendicular to n, so the compression zone is a polygon cut off the top right corner, and each bar's strain depends on its distance from that corner along n.

The rules are the same as for a single axis (ACI 318-19 Section 22.2): plane sections stay plane, the concrete crushes at 0.003, the concrete stress block is 0.85 f′c over a depth a = β1c, and the steel is elastic-plastic. What changes is the geometry:

Mθ = Mz cos θ + My sin θ

At θ = 0° this is exactly Mz and the curve is the Z curve; at θ = 90° it is My and the curve is the Y curve. The key points carry over too: P2 is still the point where Pn = 0, and P4, the balanced point, is still where the deepest bar, now measured along n, reaches yield.

How the capacity changes with the angle

Running the same 14 × 24 in column at angles from 0° to 90° shows how quickly the strength falls away from the strong axis.

0100200300400500-400-20002004006008001000Design moment, φMθ (kip-ft)Design axial load, φPn (kip), compression upθ = 0°, about Z (strong axis)θ = 45°θ = 90°, about Y (weak axis)
Design P-M curves of the 14 × 24 in column at θ = 0°, 45° and 90°, from PM Curve. The 45° curve sits well inside the strong axis curve: at pure bending it has 69% of the Z capacity.
θφMθ at φPn = 0 (kip-ft)φ at P2Balanced φPn (kip)Balanced φMθ (kip-ft)
0° (Z)414.00.90338.0373.4
15°390.30.90338.4349.4
30°348.60.893323.7307.3
45°285.20.838304.0259.4
60°233.10.812279.3215.5
75°211.00.830283.1195.3
90° (Y)222.00.90286.6216.5

Two things stand out. First, the drop is not linear: by 45° the pure bending capacity has fallen by 31%, two thirds of the way from the Z value to the Y value. Second, the lowest design values are not at 90°. At 75° the nominal balanced moment is lower than about Y (300.5 against 333.0 kip-ft), and at pure bending the deepest bar is strained less, so φ falls to 0.83. The design curve at 75° sits inside the weak axis curve. Checking the two principal axes alone can miss the weakest direction.

The neutral axis and the moment do not point the same way

The most important point about biaxial bending is easy to miss. When the neutral axis turns by θ, the resulting moment does not turn by θ. It stays closer to the strong axis, because the section is deeper in that direction and its forces have longer lever arms about Z. Here is the balanced point at each angle:

Neutral axis angle θMz (kip-ft)My (kip-ft)Direction of the moment, atan(My/Mz)
15°547.235.03.7°
30°502.575.18.5°
45°441.4123.015.6°
60°340.7186.228.7°
75°192.7259.453.4°

A neutral axis at 45° produces a moment at only 15.6°. To resist a moment acting at 45°, this column's neutral axis has to turn to between 60° and 75°. For a square section with symmetric bars the two directions agree at 45°, but for any rectangular column they do not, and the longer the section, the bigger the difference.

So when you check a load with moments about both axes, choose θ so that the capacity's moment direction matches the load's, not simply θ = atan(Muy/Muz). PM Curve's detailed report lists Mz and My at every key point, so the direction at each angle can be read off directly.

Worked example: a corner column

The same 14 × 24 in column carries Pu = 280 kip, Muz = 180 kip-ft and Muy = 100 kip-ft. The load's moment acts at atan(100 / 180) = 29.1° from Z.

Separate checks. At 280 kip the Z curve gives φMnz = 411.8 kip-ft and the Y curve φMny = 218.0 kip-ft. The ratios are 180 / 411.8 = 0.44 and 100 / 218.0 = 0.46. Each check looks comfortable.

Simple linear sum. 0.44 + 0.46 = 0.90. A common hand check, safe for this column but with little margin left.

Curve at an angle. At θ = 60° the balanced point is at φPn = 279 kip, almost exactly the load, and its moment acts at 28.7°, matching the load's 29.1°. The load's component in that direction is Muθ = 180 cos 60° + 100 sin 60° = 176.6 kip-ft. The 60° design curve gives φMθ = 216.2 kip-ft at 280 kip, so the ratio is 176.6 / 216.2 = 0.82.

The real utilization is 0.82, nearly twice what either single-axis check shows. Checking each axis on its own would have suggested the column had more than half its capacity to spare. The linear sum caught it here, but it is only an approximation: it is often very conservative, and it says nothing about which direction governs. The curve at the right angle gives the actual number.

Why it matters in column design

Using it in PM Curve

In PM Curve 1.1.0, set the curve direction to θ and enter an angle from 0° to 360°. The app draws the nominal and design curves of Pn against Mθ with the seven key points, shows the rotated section, and its detailed report gives the compression block, each bar's depth, strain and force, and Mz, My and Mθ at every point, step by step. Press the ? button to see an animation of how the rotation works. Angles of exactly 0° and 90° run the Z and Y calculations themselves, and other angles have been checked against an independent reference calculation at every point. Circular columns can also be run at any angle, with the bars measured from the bending direction.

The curve at an angle is the strength of the cross-section. Slenderness effects still need to be added to the moments first (ACI 318-19 Section 6.6.4), in both directions, before the load is plotted.

FAQ

Frequently asked questions

What is a P-M interaction curve at an angle?

It is the axial load and moment interaction curve of a column section with its neutral axis turned by an angle theta from the Z axis. It is a slice of the full biaxial strength surface, and plots Pn against M_theta = Mz cos theta + My sin theta.

Why is the P-M curve at an angle important?

Columns often carry moments about both axes at once, for example corner columns and columns under diagonal wind or 100% + 30% seismic combinations. Checking the Z and Y curves separately ignores that both moments use the same concrete and steel, and can greatly overstate the spare capacity.

Does a neutral axis at 45 degrees give a moment at 45 degrees?

Not for a rectangular column. The resulting moment stays closer to the strong axis. For a 14 x 24 in column with 10-#9 bars, a neutral axis at 45 degrees gives a moment at about 15.6 degrees at the balanced point.

How do I check a column for biaxial bending with the curve at an angle?

Find the angle theta whose capacity has the same ratio of My to Mz as the load, compute the load's Mu_theta = Muz cos theta + Muy sin theta, and compare it with phi M_theta at Pu on the design curve for that angle.

What is the difference between the curve at an angle and Bresler's method?

Bresler's reciprocal load method estimates biaxial capacity from the uniaxial capacities. The curve at an angle is calculated directly by strain compatibility with the neutral axis at the chosen angle, so it does not depend on that approximation.

Keep reading

More from the blog

For use by qualified engineers. All results must be checked independently before use in any design. See the Terms of Use.