One curve instead of two checks
A steel beam can be checked for bending, and a short strut for compression, each on its own. A reinforced concrete column cannot, because axial load and moment act on the same concrete and steel. Compression uses up concrete that would otherwise resist the moment, and below a certain load it actually helps the section resist bending, because it holds back the cracking and yielding on the tension side.
So instead of one capacity, a column has a boundary. Plot axial load P up the vertical axis and moment M along the horizontal one, and every combination the column can carry lies inside a closed curve. Any factored load combination (Pu, Mu) that falls inside the design curve is safe. One that falls outside is not.
How the curve is built
Each point on the curve is one position of the neutral axis. ACI 318-19 Section 22.2 sets the rules for finding the strength at that position:
- Plane sections stay plane, so strain varies linearly across the depth.
- The concrete crushes at a strain of 0.003 at the extreme compression fibre.
- Concrete compression is a uniform stress of 0.85 f′c over a depth a = β1c (β1 = 0.85 for 4 ksi concrete). Concrete in tension is ignored.
- Steel is elastic up to fy (Es = 29,000 ksi), then flat.
Pick a neutral axis depth c, read the strain at every bar, turn strains into stresses and forces, then add them up. The sum of the forces is Pn, and their moment about the plastic centroid (the middle, for a symmetric section) is Mn. Move c from far below the section to above it and the points trace the whole curve.
Concrete. a = 0.85 × 5.70 = 4.84 in, Cc = 0.85 × 4 × 4.84 × 12 = 198 kip, acting 3.58 in above the centre.
Steel. Top bars: strain 0.00175, stress 50.7 ksi, force 112 kip after taking off the concrete they displace. Bottom bars: at yield, 60 × 2.37 = 142 kip in tension. Middle bars: 7 kip in tension.
Axial load. Pn = 198 + 112 − 7 − 142 = 160 kip.
Moment. Mn = 198 × 3.58 + (112 + 142) × 3.625 = 1,629 kip-in = 135.8 kip-ft.
The seven key points
PM Curve reports the curve as a full sweep plus seven named points, each tied to a strain condition in the deepest bar (εt, tension positive):
| Point | Condition | Pn (kip) | Mn (kip-ft) | φ | φPn (kip) | φMn (kip-ft) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| P1 | Pure tension, all steel yields | −379.2 | 0 | 0.90 | −341.3 | 0 |
| P2 | Pure bending, Pn = 0 | 0 | 115.0 | 0.834 | 0 | 95.9 |
| P3 | Tension-controlled limit, εt = εty + 0.003 | −49.8 | 107.8 | 0.90 | −44.8 | 97.0 |
| P4 | Balanced, εt = εty = 0.00207 | 160.2 | 135.8 | 0.65 | 104.1 | 88.2 |
| P5 | Half yield, εt = 0.5 εty | 323.7 | 121.8 | 0.65 | 210.4 | 79.2 |
| P6 | Decompression, εt = 0 | 514.3 | 93.6 | 0.65 | 334.3 | 60.9 |
| P7 | Code cap, Pn = 0.80 P0 | 677.8 | 51.9 | 0.65 | 440.6 | 33.7 |
Above the balanced point the column is compression-controlled: the concrete crushes before the tension steel yields, and each extra kip of axial load costs moment capacity. Below it the tension steel yields first, the section is ductile, and in nominal terms a little compression adds moment capacity: Mn rises from 115.0 kip-ft at pure bending to 135.8 kip-ft at the balanced point.
Why the design curve is a different shape
The design curve is not just the nominal curve scaled down. Two code rules change its shape.
φ depends on the steel strain
ACI 318-19 Table 21.2.2 sets φ = 0.65 for tied columns (0.75 for spirals) when the section is compression-controlled, εt ≤ εty, and φ = 0.90 when it is tension-controlled, εt ≥ εty + 0.003. In between it varies linearly. A brittle compression failure gets the bigger safety margin.
For this column the effect is large. Between pure bending and the balanced point the nominal moment rises by 18%, but φ falls from 0.834 to 0.65, so the design moment falls from 95.9 to 88.2 kip-ft. The largest design moment, 97.0 kip-ft, is at P3, under a small net tension.
The flat top
Pure compression capacity is P0 = 0.85 f′c (Ag − Ast) + fy Ast = 847.3 kip. ACI 318-19 Table 22.4.2.1 limits a tied column to 0.80 P0 (0.85 P0 for spirals) to allow for accidental eccentricity, so the top of the curve is cut flat at φPn,max = 0.65 × 0.80 × 847.3 = 441 kip.
How to check a column with it
Plot every factored load combination as a point (Pu, Mu) and see where it falls. For the 12 × 12 in column:
| Load point | Pu (kip) | Mu (kip-ft) | φMn at that load | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A, heavy gravity | 300 compression | 55 | 66.9 kip-ft | inside, OK |
| B, moderate gravity | 100 compression | 85 | 88.8 kip-ft | inside, OK |
| C, wind uplift | 100 tension | 85 | 81.5 kip-ft | outside, fails |
B and C carry the same 100 kip and the same moment. The only difference is that in C the 100 kip is tension instead of compression, and C fails. This is the main reason the diagram matters: the governing combination is not always the one with the largest load. A combination such as 0.9D + 1.0W, with little gravity load and a large wind moment, can control a column that easily passes 1.2D + 1.6L. Without the curve you would not see it.
Why it matters in column design
- Axial load and moment cannot be checked separately. The column above carries 441 kip with no moment and 96 kip-ft with no axial load, but only 67 kip-ft at 300 kip.
- Every load combination needs checking. The one with the least compression, or with net tension, can govern.
- It shows how the section fails. Points above the balanced point fail by crushing with little warning, and points below it by yielding of the steel.
- It guides the design. Adding bars moves the whole curve out, while adding depth mostly widens it in bending. Seeing where the load points sit tells you which change is worth making.
- It shows the margin. How far each point sits from the curve tells you whether the column is close to its limit or has room to spare.
What the curve does not cover
- Slenderness. The curve is the strength of the cross-section. For a slender column, magnify the moments first (ACI 318-19 Section 6.6.4) and then plot them.
- Biaxial bending. A curve for one axis does not cover moments about both axes at once. That needs its own check.
- Reinforcement limits and detailing. ACI 318-19 Section 10.6.1.1 requires 1% to 8% longitudinal steel, and ties, spacing and shear are checked separately.
This 12 × 12 in column has 4.4% steel, inside the 1% to 8% range. The same method applies to any rectangular or circular, tied or spiral column; only the numbers change.
Try it yourself
Open PM Curve, enter the column size, the bars and the materials, and it draws the nominal and design curves with all seven key points and the φ at each, and gives a step-by-step PDF report of the calculation. Sign in, free, to compare two sections on one chart.