Verification

Checked against hand calculations and AISC tables

Each example below is worked out by hand, step by step, or taken from the AISC Steel Construction Manual, and set beside the results from Section Designer. Open any example in the app to check it yourself.

4examples
48results compared
< 0.07%off hand calculations
< 0.7%off AISC A, I, S, Z and r
Example 1

Solid rectangle, 300 × 600 mm

✓ Verified

The section

b = 300 h = 600
  • One rectangle part, b = 300, h = 600
  • Bottom left corner at the origin
Open in Section Designer

Hand calculation

A = b h = 300 × 600 = 180,000 mm²

x̄ = b/2 = 150 mm,  ȳ = h/2 = 300 mm

Ix = b h³/12 = 300 × 600³/12 = 5,400 ×10⁶ mm⁴,  Iy = h b³/12 = 1,350 ×10⁶ mm⁴

Sx = b h²/6 = 18.00 ×10⁶ mm³,  Sy = h b²/6 = 9.00 ×10⁶ mm³

Zx = b h²/4 = 27.00 ×10⁶ mm³,  Zy = h b²/4 = 13.50 ×10⁶ mm³

J = β b³h, with β = ⅓ [1 − (192/π⁵)(b/h) Σ tanh(nπh/2b)/n⁵], n = 1, 3, 5, …
For h/b = 2: β = 0.22868, so J = 0.22868 × 300³ × 600 = 3,704.6 ×10⁶ mm⁴

Cw = ∫ ω² dA, with ω the exact Saint-Venant warping function of a rectangle (series), integrated numerically: 14.815 ×10¹² mm⁶

Shear centre: on both axes of symmetry, at the centroid (150, 300)

PropertyHand calcSection DesignerDifference
A mm²180,000180,0000.000%
Centroid x̄, ȳ mm150, 300150, 3000
Ix ×10⁶ mm⁴5,400.05,400.00.000%
Iy ×10⁶ mm⁴1,350.01,350.00.000%
Sx ×10⁶ mm³18.00018.0000.000%
Sy ×10⁶ mm³9.0009.0000.000%
Zx ×10⁶ mm³27.00027.0000.000%
Zy ×10⁶ mm³13.50013.5000.000%
J ×10⁶ mm⁴3,704.63,706.5+0.050%
Cw ×10¹² mm⁶14.81514.824+0.061%
Shear centre mm150, 300150.0, 300.00

Area, centroid, I, S and Z are exact. J and Cw come from the app's finite element solution and agree with the exact series within 0.07%. Thin-walled formulas would give Cw ≈ 0 for a rectangle, but a solid rectangle does warp a little, and the app finds it.

Example 2

Hollow circle, 400 mm outside, 300 mm inside

✓ Verified

The section

D = 400 d = 300
  • A circle part, d = 400, centred on the origin
  • A circle hole, d = 300, at the same centre
Open in Section Designer

Hand calculation

A = π/4 (D² − d²) = π/4 (400² − 300²) = 54,977.9 mm²

Centroid at the centre (0, 0), by symmetry

Ix = Iy = π/64 (D⁴ − d⁴) = π/64 (400⁴ − 300⁴) = 859.03 ×10⁶ mm⁴

Sx = Sy = I / (D/2) = 859.03 ×10⁶ / 200 = 4.2951 ×10⁶ mm³

Zx = Zy = (D³ − d³)/6 = (400³ − 300³)/6 = 6.1667 ×10⁶ mm³

J = π/32 (D⁴ − d⁴) = Ix + Iy = 1,718.06 ×10⁶ mm⁴ (exact for a circular tube of any thickness)

Cw = 0: a circular tube does not warp. Shear centre at the centre (0, 0)

PropertyHand calcSection DesignerDifference
A mm²54,977.954,977.2−0.001%
Centroid x̄, ȳ mm0, 00, 00
Ix = Iy ×10⁶ mm⁴859.03859.01−0.003%
Sx = Sy ×10⁶ mm³4.29514.2950−0.003%
Zx = Zy ×10⁶ mm³6.16676.1665−0.002%
J ×10⁶ mm⁴1,718.061,717.54−0.030%
Cw mm⁶000
Shear centre mm0, 00, 00

The app traces a circle as a 720-sided polygon, so area and I come out a few thousandths of a percent low. J comes from the finite element solution and is within 0.03%.

Example 3

W14×90 against the AISC Manual

✓ Verified

The section

bf = 14.5 in d = 14.0 in
  • From the app's section library: an I section plus four root fillets
  • d = 14.0, bf = 14.5, tw = 0.440, tf = 0.710 in
  • Fillet radius kdes − tf = 1.31 − 0.71 = 0.60 in
Open in Section Designer

Reference: AISC Manual, 16th Edition, Table 1-1

The published properties of W14×90 in the AISC Steel Construction Manual, 16th Edition (AISC Shapes Database v16.0), beside what Section Designer calculates from the printed dimensions.

Hand check of the area from those dimensions:
A = 2 bf tf + (d − 2tf) tw + 4 (1 − π/4) r² = 2(14.5)(0.71) + (14.0 − 1.42)(0.44) + 4(0.2146)(0.60)² = 26.43 in², the app's value exactly.

PropertyAISC ManualSection DesignerDifference
A in²26.526.43−0.25%
Centroid inat mid-depth0, 00
Ix in⁴999994.8−0.43%
Sx in³143142.1−0.62%
Zx in³157156.1−0.55%
rx in6.146.13−0.09%
Iy in⁴362360.9−0.31%
Sy in³49.949.78−0.25%
Zy in³75.675.36−0.32%
ry in3.703.69−0.14%
J in⁴4.064.07+0.29%
Cw in⁶16,00015,830−1.06%
Shear centre inat the centroid0, 00

Why the app is a little lower: AISC works its table values out from more exact dimensions than the rounded ones it prints, and rounds the results to three figures. From the printed dimensions the area is 26.43 in², as the app finds. AISC gives Cw by the thin-walled formula Iy ho²/4, which treats the flanges as thin lines. The app's finite element solution uses the real flange thickness and fillets, so its Cw is about 1% lower.

Example 4

Channel C12×20.7: shear centre and warping, two models

✓ Verified

The AISC Manual (16th Edition, Table 1-5) works out A, I, S, Z and r from the real rolled shape, but the shear centre e₀ and the warping constant Cw from simplified thin-walled formulas. No single model can match all of them, so this example uses two. Model A is the real shape and matches the section properties. Model B is the flat-flange shape the formulas assume and matches Cw.

Model A The real rolled shape matches A, I, S, Z and r

The section

S.C. bf = 2.94 in eo d = 12 in
  • One polygon: flanges sloped 2 in 12, with root fillets and rounded flange tips
  • d = 12, bf = 2.94, tw = 0.282 in, tf = 0.501 in on average
  • The shear centre (S.C.) is outside the section, behind the web
Open in Section Designer Download the model (.json)

Reference: AISC Manual, 16th Edition, Table 1-5

The published properties of C12×20.7 in the AISC Steel Construction Manual, 16th Edition (AISC Shapes Database v16.0), beside what Section Designer calculates for the real shape.

PropertyAISC ManualSection DesignerDifference
A in²6.086.079−0.02%
x̄, centroid from back of web in0.6980.696−0.29%
Ix in⁴129129.0+0.01%
Sx in³21.521.50+0.01%
Zx in³25.625.58−0.08%
rx in4.614.607−0.07%
Iy in⁴3.863.862+0.06%
Sy, to the flange tips in³1.721.721+0.06%
Zy in³3.473.461−0.27%
ry in0.7970.797+0.01%
J in⁴0.3690.375+1.7%
e₀, shear centre behind web in0.8700.690see below
Cw in⁶11287.32see below

Why e₀ and Cw differ: AISC uses an idealised shape

For channels, AISC calculates e₀ and Cw with thin-walled open-section theory. The section becomes three flat plates along their centrelines, with the average flange thickness: b′ = bf − tw/2 = 2.799 in and h′ = d − tf = 11.499 in.

e₀ = 3b′²tf / (6b′tf + h′tw) − tw/2 = 1.010 − 0.141 = 0.869 in  (AISC: 0.870)

Cw = (tf b′³h′²/12)(3b′tf + 2h′tw) / (6b′tf + h′tw) = 111 in⁶  (AISC: 112)

Both formulas land on the table values, which confirms how they were found. The 1% between 111 and 112 most likely comes from AISC working with unrounded dimensions.

The real flanges are sloped: they carry more steel near the web and less at the tips. The tips contribute most to warping, so the real shape's Cw is about 22% lower than the table value, and its shear centre sits closer to the web. To check this independently, the same outline was solved with sectionproperties, the open-source finite element section solver widely used by engineers:

PropertyAISC (thin-walled)sectionpropertiesSection Designer
e₀, shear centre behind web in0.8700.6900.690
Cw in⁶11287.3787.32

The two solvers agree within 0.06%. As a check on the method, both give the thin-walled answers exactly when a channel's walls are made thin (1 mm), which is where those formulas hold.

Model B The flat-flange model matches Cw

The section

S.C. bf = 2.94 in eo d = 12 in
  • A channel with flat flanges of the average thickness tf = 0.501 in, plus two root fillets
  • Close to the three-plate shape behind the thin-walled formulas
  • Not the real shape: it carries extra steel at the flange tips
Open in Section Designer Download the model (.json)

Reference: AISC Manual, 16th Edition, Table 1-5

Solved as a solid section, the flat-flange model reproduces the table's warping constant. Its other properties move away from the table, because its flanges are thicker at the tips than the real ones.

PropertyAISC ManualSection DesignerDifference
Cw in⁶112112.4+0.4%
J in⁴0.3690.359−2.7%
e₀, shear centre behind web in0.8700.813−6.6%
A in²6.086.217+2.3%
Ix in⁴129133.6+3.6%
Iy in⁴3.864.835+25%

sectionproperties gives the same results for this model: Cw = 112.4 in⁶ and e₀ = 0.813 in. The thin-walled e₀ of 0.870 in is measured on centrelines, so a solid model of any thickness lands a little short of it.

What this means in practice

  • One model can't match all five AISC values (A, Ix, Iy, J, Cw), because AISC works them out with different methods. This is not a modelling error in either model.
  • For the behaviour of the real section, such as warping stresses or a torsion analysis, Cw ≈ 87 in⁶ from Model A is the more accurate value. AISC's 112 in⁶ is a design convention.
  • For design checks to AISC 360 (lateral-torsional and flexural-torsional buckling), use the tabulated J = 0.369 in⁴ and Cw = 112 in⁶, since the Specification is applied with the tabulated values. Model B reproduces Cw if you need it from the app.
  • Section Designer always solves the solid section by finite elements. It has no thin-walled mode, so a real-shape model gives about 87 in⁶, and only a flat-flange model gives about 112.

The full story, with what warping is and why the sloped flanges lower Cw: Why your FE software doesn't match the AISC Cw for a channel.

How these are kept

Checked on every release

Every example on this page is part of the app's automatic checks. Before a new version of Section Designer goes live, its results for these sections are compared again with the hand calculations, and the release stops if any differs by more than 0.1% from a hand calculation, or 0.5 to 3% from an AISC table value, depending on the property. Values from the independent sectionproperties solver are held to 0.1 to 0.2%.

More examples are on the way: built-up girders, sections with holes, and angles with their principal axes. See how the properties are calculated.

For use by qualified engineers. All results must be checked independently before use in any design. See the Terms of Use.