Why your FE software doesn't match the AISC Cw for a channel, and why that's fine

Model a C12X20.7 accurately and every property matches the AISC Manual to 0.3%, except two: the warping constant comes out 22% low and the shear centre sits closer to the web. Neither the software nor the Manual is wrong. They answer slightly different questions.

Section Designer · 7 min read

The result that looks wrong

Here is a C12X20.7 modelled in Section Designer exactly as it is rolled, with flanges sloped 2 in 12, root fillets and rounded flange tips, with every result compared with the AISC Steel Construction Manual, 16th Edition, Table 1-5.

PropertyAISC ManualReal shape, Section DesignerDifference
Area, A6.08 in²6.079 in²−0.02%
Ix129 in⁴129.0 in⁴+0.01%
Iy3.86 in⁴3.862 in⁴+0.06%
Sx / Zx21.5 / 25.6 in³21.50 / 25.58 in³within 0.1%
Sy / Zy1.72 / 3.47 in³1.721 / 3.461 in³within 0.3%
rx / ry4.61 / 0.797 in4.607 / 0.797 inwithin 0.1%
Torsion constant, J0.369 in⁴0.375 in⁴+1.7%
Shear centre behind the web, e00.870 in0.690 in−21%
Warping constant, Cw112 in⁶87.3 in⁶−22%

Nine properties agree to a fraction of a percent. Two are a fifth out. Is the software wrong?

What Cw and e0 measure

When an open section such as a channel twists, its cross-section does not stay flat. The flanges bend in their own plane in opposite directions, so points along the section move along the member's length by different amounts. This out-of-plane movement is warping. If the supports or the rest of the member stop the section warping freely, the flanges carry extra bending stresses and the member is stiffer in twist. The warping constant Cw measures how much: it sums the square of the warping displacement over the area, and the flange tips, which move the most, count by far the most.

The shear centre is the point a transverse load must pass through for the section to bend without twisting. For a channel it lies outside the section, behind the web, at a distance e0. A load applied through the web is off the shear centre, which is why channels twist under it unless they are braced.

Both values feed the lateral-torsional and flexural-torsional buckling checks, so the difference is worth understanding.

S.C. e0 d = 12 in A: the real shape S.C. e0 d = 12 in B: flat flanges
The two models, drawn to scale: d = 12 in, bf = 2.94 in, tw = 0.282 in. Model A has the real sloped flanges, thick at the web and thin at the tips. Model B has flat flanges of the average thickness, 0.501 in. The circle with a cross is the centroid. The amber dot is the shear centre, behind the web.

How AISC works out Cw and e0

For channels, the Manual takes A, I, S, Z and r from the real rolled shape, but e0 and Cw from thin-walled open-section theory. The section becomes three flat plates along their centrelines, with the flanges at their average thickness. For the C12X20.7, with d = 12 in, bf = 2.94 in, tw = 0.282 in and tf = 0.501 in:

Centreline dimensions. b′ = bf − tw / 2 = 2.799 in and h′ = d − tf = 11.499 in.

Shear centre. e0 = 3 b′² tf / (6 b′ tf + h′ tw) − tw / 2 = 1.010 − 0.141 = 0.869 in (AISC: 0.870).

Warping constant. Cw = (tf b′³ h′² / 12) (3 b′ tf + 2 h′ tw) / (6 b′ tf + h′ tw) = 111 in⁶ (AISC: 112).

Both formulas land on the table values, which shows how the table was made. The last 1% most likely comes from AISC working with unrounded dimensions.

Why the real shape warps less

A rolled channel's flanges are not flat. They slope, so there is more steel near the web and less at the tips, even though the average thickness is the same 0.501 in. The tips are exactly where warping displacements are largest, and Cw grows with the square of them, so taking steel away from the tips lowers Cw sharply: from 112 to about 87 in⁶, 22% less.

The same shift moves the shear centre. With less steel out at the tips, the flanges carry a smaller share of the shear flow, and the shear centre moves towards the web: 0.690 in instead of 0.870 in.

An independent check

To make sure this is not a quirk of one program, the same outline was solved with sectionproperties, the open-source finite element section solver many engineers use:

PropertyAISC (thin-walled)sectionpropertiesSection Designer
e00.870 in0.690 in0.690 in
Cw112 in⁶87.37 in⁶87.32 in⁶

The two solvers agree within 0.06%. As a check on the method, both give the thin-walled answers when the channel's walls are made very thin (1 mm), which is where those formulas hold.

Model B: the shape the formulas assume

If the difference really comes from the flange slope, a channel with flat flanges of the average thickness should reproduce the table's Cw. It does, and it shows the other side of the trade:

PropertyAISC ManualFlat flanges, Section DesignerDifference
Cw112 in⁶112.4 in⁶+0.4%
J0.369 in⁴0.359 in⁴−2.7%
e00.870 in0.813 in−6.6%
A6.08 in²6.217 in²+2.3%
Ix129 in⁴133.6 in⁴+3.6%
Iy3.86 in⁴4.835 in⁴+25%

Cw now matches, but A, Ix and especially Iy move away, because this shape has extra steel at the flange tips that the real channel does not. e0 still falls a little short of 0.870 in, because the thin-walled value is measured on centrelines and a solid model of any thickness lands slightly inside it. sectionproperties again gives the same numbers: Cw = 112.4 in⁶ and e0 = 0.813 in.

What this means in practice

Section Designer always solves the solid section by finite elements. It has no thin-walled mode, so a real-shape model gives about 87 in⁶ and only a flat-flange model gives about 112 in⁶. Expect the same kind of gap on other rolled channels with sloped flanges, and check the shape before you compare.

Try it yourself

Both models are Example 4 on the Section Designer verified examples page, with every value compared and both models to download or open in the app. Section Designer works out J, Cw and the shear centre by finite elements for any section you build, so you can try the same comparison on your own channels.

FAQ

Frequently asked questions

Why is the AISC Cw for a channel larger than my finite element result?

AISC calculates Cw for channels with thin-walled formulas that treat the section as three flat plates of the average flange thickness. Real rolled channels have sloped flanges with less steel at the tips, where warping is largest, so a finite element model of the real shape gives a lower Cw. For a C12X20.7 it is 87 in⁶ against 112 in⁶.

Which Cw should I use in AISC 360 buckling checks?

Use the tabulated values from the AISC Manual, J = 0.369 in⁴ and Cw = 112 in⁶ for a C12X20.7. The Specification is applied with the tabulated properties. Use the finite element value when you need the real section's behaviour, such as warping stresses.

Where is the shear centre of a channel?

Outside the section, behind the web. AISC lists e₀ = 0.870 in for a C12X20.7 from thin-walled theory. A finite element model of the real sloped-flange shape puts it at 0.690 in, closer to the web.

Is the finite element result or the AISC table wrong?

Neither. They describe different shapes: the finite element model is the real rolled channel, and the table value is for three flat plates of the average thickness. A flat-flange model in Section Designer gives Cw = 112.4 in⁶, within 0.4% of the table.

Keep reading

More from the blog

For use by qualified engineers. All results must be checked independently before use in any design. See the Terms of Use.