The numbers
Both sections opened from the library in Section Designer, which works out the gross properties from the actual outline:
| 4CS2.5x105 cold-formed, AISI | C3X4.1 hot-rolled, AISC | Cold-formed | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Area, A | 1.043 in² | 1.215 in² | 14% less |
| Weight | 3.55 lb/ft | 4.1 lb/ft | 13% lighter |
| Strong axis, Ix | 2.675 in⁴ | 1.667 in⁴ | 60% more |
| Weak axis, Iy | 0.937 in⁴ | 0.199 in⁴ | 4.7 times |
| Section modulus, Sx | 1.338 in³ | 1.112 in³ | 20% more |
| Radius of gyration, ry | 0.948 in | 0.405 in | 2.3 times |
| Torsion constant, J | 0.0038 in⁴ | 0.0269 in⁴ | 7 times less |
The C3X4.1 values are for Section Designer's model of the rolled shape with its sloped flanges. The AISC Manual lists A = 1.20 in², Ix = 1.65 in⁴ and Iy = 0.191 in⁴, all within 4% of the model, so the comparison holds with either set. The 4CS2.5x105 values match the AISI table, and J for the C3X4.1 is the AISC value.
Why less steel gives more stiffness
The second moment of area adds up every bit of area times the square of its distance from the axis:
I = ∫ y² dA
So a square inch of steel 2 in from the axis adds 4 in⁴, while the same square inch 1 in from the axis adds only 1 in⁴. Where the steel sits matters far more than how much of it there is. Three things put the cold-formed channel's steel farther out:
- Thin walls make a bigger shape. A 0.105 in sheet spreads slightly less steel over a 4 × 2.5 in outline, against 3 × 1.41 in for the rolled channel.
- The rolled channel keeps steel near the axis. Its web is 0.17 in thick, and the web is the part that does least for Ix and almost nothing for Iy.
- The lips put steel at the flange tips, the points farthest from the y axis. That is the main reason Iy is almost five times larger.
Is it a fair comparison?
The sections are not the same depth, and a good part of the Ix gain comes from the extra inch. That is the point, though: with thin sheet, the same weight of steel can be formed into a deeper section. Per pound, the cold-formed channel gives 0.75 in⁴ of Ix for each lb/ft, against 0.41 for the rolled one. The deeper section does need more room, which matters in a wall or floor of fixed depth.
The catch: thin walls
- Stiffness is not strength. I and S tell you how much a section deflects and how stress spreads in it. A thin, flat wall can buckle locally under compression before it yields, so cold-formed members are designed with effective section properties to AISI S100, which leave out the parts of the walls that buckle. The gross values above are for stiffness, not for the strength check.
- Distortional buckling. Lipped channels can also buckle by the flange and lip rotating about the web corner, which AISI S100 checks separately.
- Torsion. J depends on the wall thickness cubed, so thin open sections are very flexible in twist: 0.0038 in⁴ here against 0.0269 in⁴. Channels of both kinds also have their shear centre outside the web, so a load through the web twists them unless they are braced.
- Concentrated loads and connections. A thin web can cripple under a point load or at a bearing, and connections are usually screws rather than welds or large bolts.
When to use which
Cold-formed sections are light and stiff for repeated, evenly loaded, braced members: wall studs, floor joists, purlins and girts, where the sheathing or deck holds the flanges. Hot-rolled channels are the robust choice for heavier and concentrated loads, for members that are hard to brace, and where the connections are welded or bolted.
Check it yourself
Open Section Designer and insert both sections from the library: the 4CS2.5x105 from the AISI C-sections with lips, and the C3X4.1 from the AISC C channels. The properties panel shows every value in the table above, and you can place the two side by side on the canvas. For a channel of your own dimensions, the free channel calculator shows the working step by step. And for what the elastic and plastic moduli of these sections mean, see elastic vs plastic section modulus.