Elastic vs plastic section modulus: S vs Z

Both measure how much bending a section can take, but at different moments: S at the first yield of the extreme fibre, Z once the whole section has yielded. Here is how to calculate each, and why the difference matters.

Section Designer · 8 min read

The short answer

Section Fy First yieldM = Fy S Fy Partly plasticFy S < M < Fy Z Fy Fully plasticM = Fy Z
Bending stress through the depth as the moment grows. Compression is drawn to the right, tension to the left. The stress stays linear until the outer fibres reach Fy, then the yielded zones spread inwards until the whole section is at Fy.

Elastic section modulus, S

While the steel is elastic, bending stress grows in a straight line from zero at the neutral axis, which passes through the centroid, to its largest value at the fibre farthest from it. That gives the familiar σ = M c / I, and the elastic section modulus collects the geometry into one number:

S = I / c    so    σmax = M / S

Here I is the second moment of area about the centroidal axis and c is the distance from that axis to the extreme fibre. A section that is not symmetric about the axis has two values, one to each face. The smaller one governs first yield.

Plastic section modulus, Z

Keep increasing the moment and the yielded zones spread in from both faces until every fibre is at Fy, in compression on one side and tension on the other. The force on each side is then Fy times its area, and because there is no axial load the two forces must be equal. So the plastic neutral axis (PNA) is the line that divides the section into two equal areas, which is not always the centroid.

Z = Ac yc + At yt,   with Ac = At = A / 2

yc and yt are the distances from the PNA to the centroids of the compression and tension halves. In words, Z is the sum of the first moments of the two halves about the PNA. For a section that is symmetric about the bending axis, such as a rectangle, a circle or a doubly symmetric I beam, the PNA and the centroid coincide.

Example 1: a rectangle

Take a solid rectangle b = 4 in wide and h = 12 in deep, bent about its strong axis.

Elastic. I = b h³ / 12 = 4 × 12³ / 12 = 576 in⁴, and c = h / 2 = 6 in, so S = 576 / 6 = 96 in³. In general S = b h² / 6.

Plastic. The PNA is at mid-depth. Each half is 4 × 6 = 24 in² with its centroid 3 in from the PNA, so Z = 24 × 3 + 24 × 3 = 144 in³. In general Z = b h² / 4.

Shape factor. Z / S = 144 / 96 = 1.5, for every rectangle. Once the extreme fibres yield, the section still has 50% more moment to give before it is fully plastic.

Example 2: a T section, where the two axes part

A tee 6 in deep with a 6 × 0.5 in flange and a 0.5 in thick stem shows what happens when the section is not symmetric about the bending axis.

Plastic NA, 0.479 in below top Elastic NA (centroid), 1.685 in below top 6 in deep, flange 6 × 0.5 in, stem 0.5 in
The elastic neutral axis passes through the centroid. The plastic neutral axis splits the area in half, and it sits inside the flange because the flange alone holds more than half of the area.

Area. Flange 6 × 0.5 = 3.00 in², stem 0.5 × 5.5 = 2.75 in², total A = 5.75 in².

Centroid, from the bottom of the stem: ȳ = (2.75 × 2.75 + 3.00 × 5.75) / 5.75 = 4.315 in, which is 1.685 in below the top.

Second moment of area, by the parallel axis theorem: stem 0.5 × 5.5³ / 12 + 2.75 × 1.565² = 13.670 in⁴, flange 6 × 0.5³ / 12 + 3.00 × 1.435² = 6.238 in⁴, so Ix = 19.908 in⁴.

Elastic moduli. To the top of the flange S = 19.908 / 1.685 = 11.82 in³. To the tip of the stem S = 19.908 / 4.315 = 4.613 in³, which governs first yield.

Plastic neutral axis. Half the area is 2.875 in², less than the flange's 3.00 in², so the PNA is in the flange, 2.875 / 6 = 0.479 in below the top.

Plastic modulus. Above the PNA: 2.875 × 0.240 = 0.689 in³. Below it, the last 0.021 in of flange: 0.125 × 0.010 = 0.001 in³, and the stem: 2.75 × (0.021 + 2.75) = 7.620 in³. So Z = 8.310 in³.

Shape factor. Z / Smin = 8.310 / 4.613 = 1.80. The stem yields early because it is far from the centroid, so a tee bent with its stem in tension has a lot of strength left after first yield.

These are the same numbers the free T section calculator shows for d = 6, bf = 6, tf = 0.5 and tw = 0.5 in, with every step written out for your own dimensions.

Shape factors of common sections

SectionBending axisZ / S
W14X90 (AISC: Zx 157, Sx 143 in³)Strong (x)1.10
Thin-walled round tubeAnyabout 1.27 (4 / π)
RectangleEither1.50
W14X90 (AISC: Zy 75.6, Sy 49.9 in³)Weak (y)1.52
Solid circleAny1.70 (16 / 3π)
The tee above, stem in tensionx, to the stem tip1.80
Square bent about its diagonalDiagonal2.00

The pattern is that the more of the area sits close to the neutral axis, the higher the shape factor. An I beam about its strong axis already has most of its steel in the flanges, at the extreme fibres, so it is almost fully stressed at first yield and has little extra to give. A diamond has very little steel at its tips, so yielding them hardly matters.

Where each one is used in AISC 360

For a W14X90 with Fy = 50 ksi, first yield is at My = 50 × 143 / 12 = 596 kip-ft and the plastic moment is Mp = 50 × 157 / 12 = 654 kip-ft, 10% more. This shape is a good reminder to check compactness first: its flanges are noncompact at 50 ksi (bf / 2tf = 10.2, over the 9.15 limit), so Section F3 gives a nominal moment a little below Mp.

Watch the letters. AISC uses S for elastic and Z for plastic. The older British code BS 5950 uses them the other way round, Z for elastic and S for plastic, and Eurocode 3 writes Wel and Wpl. Check which convention a table uses before you take a value from it.

Calculate S and Z for your own section

The free shape calculators give S and Z with the working shown: rectangle, I beam, T section, channel, angle, HSS tube and hollow circle. For any other shape, including built-up sections and AISC and AISI steel shapes, Section Designer works out both moduli to every face and draws the elastic and plastic neutral axes on the section.

FAQ

Frequently asked questions

Is the plastic section modulus always larger than the elastic one?

Yes. Z is at least as large as the smaller elastic modulus S for any section, because a fully yielded section carries at least the moment it carried at first yield. The ratio Z/S is the shape factor, from about 1.1 for an I beam about its strong axis to 2 for a diamond.

Where is the plastic neutral axis?

It is the line that divides the section into two equal areas, so the compression and tension forces balance once the whole section has yielded. For sections symmetric about the bending axis it passes through the centroid. For unsymmetric sections such as tees it does not.

When do I use Z instead of S?

Use Z for the plastic moment Mp = Fy Z, which is the flexural strength of compact, laterally braced steel sections in AISC 360. Use S for first yield, elastic stresses and as part of the lateral-torsional buckling and noncompact section equations.

Why do some tables use Z for the elastic modulus?

The letters depend on the code. AISC uses S for elastic and Z for plastic, the British BS 5950 uses Z for elastic and S for plastic, and Eurocode 3 uses Wel and Wpl. Check the convention before taking a value from a table.

Keep reading

More from the blog

For use by qualified engineers. All results must be checked independently before use in any design. See the Terms of Use.